French MEP Virginie Joron (Patriots for Europe) has submitted a written parliamentary question to the European Commission, challenging whether Spain diverted over EUR 10 billion of EU post-COVID recovery funds to pay civil service pensions in 2024-2025, and demanding to know how much of that sum was effectively funded by French taxpayers.
The question, dated 27 May 2026, cites a report by the Spanish Court of Auditors stating that in 2024, EUR 2.4 billion of 'surplus appropriations' from the EU recovery fund were used to meet unavoidable obligations related to civil service pensions. Joron further claims that in 2025, the Spanish Socialist Government diverted at least another EUR 8.5 billion to fund pensions, minimum income benefits and other social spending, referencing Spanish media reports. The Court of Auditors reportedly noted that the legal basis for those transactions should have been better justified.
Three concrete asks
Joron's question contains three specific demands. First, she asks the Commission to confirm whether the Spanish Government used over EUR 10 billion from EU funds to pay civil servants' pensions in 2024-2025. Second, she requests a breakdown of how much of that sum was funded by France and the French people. Third, she asks whether the Commission would authorise the French Government to use EU post-COVID recovery funds to finance its own pensions and social spending, and what the deadline for the last application would be.
Policy orientation and implications
The question reflects a sovereignty and fiscal fairness cleavage: Joron implicitly argues that EU recovery funds, intended for investment and reform, should not be used to cover routine social expenditure such as pensions. By singling out Spain and demanding a bilateral accounting of French contributions, she challenges the principle of solidarity embedded in the EU's joint borrowing mechanism. The question also pressures the Commission to clarify the permissible scope of recovery fund spending, potentially tightening rules if it finds Spain's use non-compliant.
Expected follow-up
The Commission is required to reply within approximately six weeks. Its answer will signal whether it considers the Spanish transfers a breach of recovery fund conditions or a legitimate flexibility measure. A finding of non-compliance could lead to repayment demands or adjustments to Spain's payment requests, while a permissive answer may open the door for other member states to follow suit. The response will also indicate the Commission's stance on the fungibility of EU funds for national social security systems. Joron's question thus serves as a probe into the enforcement of EU fiscal rules and the political limits of cross-border solidarity.
← Atlas › News › Budget & Administration